The Revolving Door of Career Growth: Why Workers Join and Leave Companies for the Same Reasons

The modern workplace is defined by a paradoxical trend: the very factors that attract talent to an organization are frequently the catalysts for their departure. Recent empirical research published by global HR research and advisory firm McLean & Co. sheds light on this phenomenon, revealing a striking alignment between the feedback provided by newly onboarded workers and those exiting their roles. According to the studies, career growth, development opportunities, and professional trajectory stand as universal priorities that dictate both entry and exit decisions.
As businesses navigate a continuously evolving labor market complicated by economic pressures, shifting employee expectations, and organizational restructuring, human resources leaders are being forced to reevaluate how they manage the entire employee lifecycle. The insights provided by McLean & Co.’s dual reports—the New Hire Survey and the Exit Survey—offer a comprehensive diagnostic blueprint for understanding why companies excel at making stellar first impressions yet struggle to retain institutional knowledge over the long term.
Bridging the Gap Between Onboarding and Offboarding
For decades, organizations have tended to treat the beginning and end of an employee’s tenure as entirely separate administrative milestones. Onboarding has traditionally been viewed through the lens of compliance, culture integration, and early productivity, while offboarding has been handled as a procedural exit interview, often chalking departures up to inevitable personal changes, better compensation offers elsewhere, or retirement.
However, McLean & Co.’s findings challenge this siloed approach. The research highlights a profound connection between new hire sentiment and exit feedback, demonstrating that the initial promises made during the recruitment process often fail to materialize as the worker settles into the daily reality of the job.
Laura Hansen-Kohls, senior vice president of HR diagnostics, advisory, and data insights at McLean, emphasized the necessity of examining these two data sets in tandem. In a public statement accompanying the release of the data, Hansen-Kohls noted that while a positive hiring experience generates valuable early momentum, it does not guarantee that employees will perceive a viable, long-term future within the organization. She stressed that when the primary reason individuals join a company mirrors the exact reason they ultimately leave, it serves as an undeniable signal that leadership must heed. Analyzing onboarding and exit data together exposes whether workers are receiving clear performance expectations, meaningful professional development, and credible pathways for advancement once the honeymoon phase of employment concludes.

Dissecting the New Hire Experience: High Hopes vs. Reality
To understand where the employee lifecycle begins to fracture, McLean & Co.’s New Hire Survey analyzed four foundational pillars of the early worker experience: the recruitment and hiring process, workplace acclimatization, training and development structures, and performance expectations.
The findings exposed a distinct hierarchy in how new employees evaluate their transition into an organization. Recruitment and hiring ranked highest among respondents, capturing an impressive 94.4% positive response rate. This high score suggests that contemporary talent acquisition teams have largely mastered the art of candidate engagement, employer branding, and interviewing. Organizations are demonstrably effective at showcasing their culture, outlining prospective job duties, and convincing top-tier talent to sign offer letters.
Conversely, performance expectations ranked the lowest among the four categories evaluated, registering at 86.3% positive responses. While an 86% approval rating might seem respectable on paper, the disparity between the 94.4% hiring score and the performance expectations score highlights a dangerous chasm. Companies are excelling at putting their best foot forward during the courting phase, but they frequently falter when it comes to maintaining role clarity, establishing measurable metrics, and delivering consistent feedback after the ink on the contract has dried.
This drop-off in satisfaction creates an early vulnerability. When a new hire steps into a role expecting dynamic career progression and transparent guidance, only to encounter ambiguous responsibilities and shifting targets, the foundation of trust established during the recruitment phase begins to erode.
The Drivers of Departure: Beyond Personal Motivations
While the New Hire Survey examined the friction points of entering an organization, the Exit Survey looked at the macro and micro influences driving workers away. To establish granular clarity, the survey separated personal reasons for leaving—such as relocation, family obligations, or health issues—from broader organizational and structural influences.
The results complicate the traditional narrative that employees leave primarily for external reasons. Personal factors did register significantly, appearing among the top three reasons for departure for 53

.6% of exiting employees. However, organizational and job-related factors closely followed, proving that internal corporate levers play a massive role in retention.
Job-specific factors were cited by 41.5% of departing workers as a primary driver for leaving, followed by compensation concerns at 37.3%, and broader organizational factors at 37.2%. These figures demonstrate that while life events do pull workers away from their current employers, a significant majority of departures are heavily influenced by elements that fall squarely within the control of corporate leadership.
The report urges human resources professionals to focus their retention strategies on variables they can actively manage. These include structured career development frameworks, intelligent job design, competitive and equitable compensation packages, effective leadership training, robust manager support, and sustainable working conditions. By addressing these internal pillars, companies can neutralize the controllable triggers that prompt valuable personnel to update their resumes.
The Broader Economic Landscape: Cost of Living and Ghost Growth
The findings from McLean & Co. arrive against a turbulent macroeconomic backdrop that has fundamentally altered how employees view their professional futures. Stagnant wage growth weighed against relentless cost-of-living increases has created a climate of widespread career anxiety.
Recent data underscores this psychological shift in the workforce. A separate benchmark report revealed that one in four respondents now feels noticeably less confident in their ability to build and maintain a stable career path compared to just a year prior. Inflationary pressures have forced workers to adopt a more transactional view of employment, where job security and financial growth supersede abstract cultural perks.
Compounding this anxiety is a rising workplace phenomenon known as "ghost growth." This term describes a scenario where employees experience the illusion of upward mobility—such as receiving expanded job titles, heavier workloads, or nominal horizontal promotions—without any of the corresponding pay increases, authority boosts, or structural benefits that traditionally accompany career advancement. Employees trapped in ghost growth cycles realize that their additional responsibilities are not translating into tangible financial security, making them prime candidates for turnover.

When ghost growth is paired with the disconnect identified in McLean’s onboarding data—where high initial expectations give way to murky performance guidelines—the risk of attrition skyrockets. Workers quickly discern whether an organization’s promises of "abundant room for growth" are genuine or merely marketing tactics designed to fill vacant seats.
Strategic Implications for Human Resources Leaders
The synthesis of McLean & Co.’s New Hire and Exit surveys provides a clear roadmap for corporate leaders seeking to stabilize their workforces and protect their bottom lines. High employee turnover is a notoriously expensive challenge, encompassing not only direct recruitment and training expenses, but also the intangible costs of lost institutional knowledge, diminished team morale, and disrupted project timelines.
To disrupt the cycle of attracting talent only to lose them to the same unresolved issues, HR departments must implement a continuous feedback loop that connects recruitment promises with long-term career management. Key strategic shifts recommended by workplace experts include:
- Honesty in Advertising: Recruitment teams must ensure that job descriptions and interview conversations accurately reflect the day-to-day realities and current challenges of the role, rather than painting an idealized picture that the organization cannot support.
- Structured Onboarding Extensions: Organizations need to extend onboarding programs beyond the first week or month. Providing continuous check-ins during the first 90 to 180 days helps ensure that performance expectations remain clear and that new hires feel supported as they navigate their responsibilities.
- Transparent Growth Pathways: Companies must dismantle ghost growth by tying increased responsibilities directly to clear compensation benchmarks, professional development milestones, and legitimate advancement opportunities. Employees need to see a clear, credible future within the organization.
- Unified Data Analysis: HR leaders should routinely cross-reference exit interview data with new hire survey results. By identifying patterns where early enthusiasm turns into later disillusionment, companies can proactively address systemic bottlenecks before they trigger mass resignations.
Ultimately, McLean & Co.’s research serves as a timely reminder that employee retention is not achieved through superficial perks or polished recruitment campaigns. True retention is built upon a sustained commitment to clarity, growth, and organizational integrity from the moment a candidate reads a job posting to the day they transition out of the firm.







