Legal & Compliance

Beyond the Timesheet: The Department of Labor’s New Guidance on FMLA Eligibility Calculations and the Burden of Proof

Payroll systems often serve as the primary source of truth for human resources departments, providing a tidy snapshot of an employee’s scheduled hours, salary status, and leave accruals. However, a significant new opinion letter issued by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) on November 17, 2026, serves as a stark reminder that payroll records and actual hours worked are not always synonymous. The guidance, officially designated as FMLA2026-3, clarifies that work performed outside of traditional scheduled hours, including documentation tasks completed at home and travel between various worksites, must be factored into the 1,250-hour eligibility requirement under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Crucially, the DOL has underscored that when employers fail to maintain accurate records, the legal burden shifts to the employer to prove that an employee has not met the threshold for FMLA protection—a standard that applies even to exempt employees who are not typically subject to rigid timekeeping requirements.

The Chronology of the Inquiry
The inquiry that prompted this administrative clarification originated from a school district occupational therapist. The employee maintained a standard seven-hour workday; however, her professional obligations extended well beyond the classroom environment. Her role required the completion of individualized education program (IEP) assessments, the preparation of complex quarterly progress reports, and mandatory travel between multiple school facilities. The therapist frequently performed these essential administrative duties at home during evening or weekend hours.

Although the employee’s supervisors were fully aware that she was performing these critical tasks outside of her established schedule, the school district did not require—nor did it track—these additional hours. When the question of FMLA eligibility arose, the district faced a dilemma: should the "scheduled" hours be the sole metric for determining eligibility, or must the employer account for the "off-the-clock" labor known to be performed? The DOL’s response was unequivocal: the FMLA, by design, incorporates the principles of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) when calculating hours of service. Consequently, any work an employer knows, or has reason to believe, is being performed—regardless of whether it was explicitly requested—must be counted toward the 1,250-hour requirement.

Defining the 1,250-Hour Threshold
To understand the gravity of the DOL’s position, one must examine the baseline requirements for FMLA eligibility. Under the statute, an employee is entitled to FMLA leave if they have worked for a covered employer for at least 12 months, work at a location where the employer employs at least 50 people within a 75-mile radius, and have accumulated at least 1,250 hours of actual service in the 12-month period immediately preceding the start of the leave.

The legal framework for this calculation is rooted in 29 C.F.R. § 825.110(c), which explicitly mandates the use of FLSA principles. Under these standards, the "workweek" includes all time during which an employee is necessarily required or permitted to perform duties for the benefit of the employer. This includes work performed at home, provided the employer is aware of the activity. Regarding the therapist’s specific case, the DOL noted that while an ordinary home-to-work commute is generally non-compensable and does not count toward hours of service, travel performed between two different worksites during the course of the workday is considered compensable time. Thus, the time spent driving between schools is highly likely to be included in the total hours-of-service calculation.

The Burden of Proof: Shifting the Responsibility
Perhaps the most consequential aspect of Opinion Letter FMLA2026-3 is its clarification on the evidentiary burden. Employers frequently operate under the assumption that if an employee is exempt from overtime—such as a teacher or a salaried professional—the employer has no obligation to track their hours, and therefore, no obligation to account for them when evaluating FMLA eligibility. The DOL has effectively dismantled this assumption.

When an employer fails to track the actual hours worked by an employee, the regulations place the burden on the employer to demonstrate that the employee has not, in fact, met the 1,250-hour threshold. This means that if an employee claims they have performed sufficient work outside of their scheduled hours to qualify for FMLA, the employer cannot simply rely on an empty payroll record to deny the claim. Instead, the employer must proactively substantiate that the claimed work did not occur, could not have occurred, or does not qualify as work under FLSA standards.

Before You Deny FMLA Leave, Are You Sure the Employee Hasn’t Worked 1,250 Hours?

For school districts and large organizations that employ salaried professionals who frequently work off-site or after hours, this creates a significant administrative hurdle. It is no longer sufficient to point to a contract or a standard work schedule. The employer must possess the data to prove a negative—that the hours were not worked—or be prepared to accept the employee’s representation of their time.

Broader Implications for Human Resources
The implications of this guidance extend far beyond the educational sector. Across various industries, the prevalence of remote work, mobile technology, and the "always-on" culture of modern professional life means that work is increasingly untethered from the traditional nine-to-five office environment. Many exempt employees, such as consultants, software engineers, and medical professionals, regularly perform "hidden" work that is rarely recorded in formal systems.

For HR departments, the DOL’s stance necessitates a shift in how FMLA eligibility is audited. Relying solely on a "snapshot" of a payroll system may lead to wrongful denials of FMLA leave, which exposes organizations to significant legal liability and potential litigation. If an employer denies leave based on a flawed hours calculation, they risk violating the FMLA’s interference and retaliation provisions, which carry heavy penalties and mandatory back-pay requirements.

To mitigate these risks, organizations should consider the following best practices:

  1. Standardizing Documentation: If an organization does not wish to track all hours for exempt employees, it should at least implement a mechanism to record specific, compensable activities that occur outside of the normal workday. This creates a contemporaneous record that can be used to accurately determine FMLA eligibility when the need arises.
  2. Training Management: Supervisors are often the first to know when an employee is working extra hours at home. Training managers to recognize that their awareness of "off-the-clock" work has legal consequences for the company is essential. Managers must understand that allowing or encouraging "extra" work without oversight can lead to unexpected FMLA eligibility.
  3. Reviewing Eligibility Policies: Policies regarding FMLA eligibility should be updated to reflect that the 1,250-hour test is a calculation of actual service, not just scheduled hours. When an employee requests leave, the initial assessment should include an inquiry into whether there is a possibility that their unrecorded hours would push them over the eligibility threshold.

The "Chaotic" Nature of Record-Keeping
The image of a chaotic detective scene, often used to illustrate the confusion surrounding complex labor laws, is an apt metaphor for the current state of FMLA administration. Without a rigorous, unified system for documenting work performed, employers are left in a state of investigative uncertainty. The DOL’s opinion letter essentially forces employers to become "detectives" of their own payroll, tasked with reconstructing the actual activities of their staff to ensure compliance.

While this may appear to be an increase in administrative burden, it is fundamentally a move toward greater transparency in labor relations. By aligning FMLA eligibility with the reality of how work is performed—rather than how it is contractually scheduled—the DOL is ensuring that the protections of the FMLA remain accessible to those who are truly performing the requisite amount of labor.

In conclusion, Opinion Letter FMLA2026-3 serves as a definitive warning: the era of relying on "scheduled hours" as a proxy for actual work is coming to an end. For employers, the lesson is clear. Whether the employee is a teacher traveling between schools or an exempt professional working from a home office, the reality of the work performed dictates the eligibility for leave. Organizations that fail to adapt their timekeeping and documentation practices to capture these realities will find themselves at a disadvantage when challenged, bearing the full weight of the burden of proof in an increasingly complex regulatory landscape. The transition toward more robust tracking is not merely an administrative upgrade; it is a critical safeguard against the risks of non-compliance.

Related Articles

Back to top button